Cranial disparity versus diversity in sabertoothed felids: a case of late morphospace saturation

Marco Romano

Abstract


In this contribution I present the first diversity (number of taxa) versus disparity (explored morphospace) comparison of sabertoothed felids performed on craniomandibular and dental characters. The graphs obtained demostrate how the morphospace exploration gradually increases in the group through time, reaching a maximum in the late Pliocene and during the Pleistocene. The latter time bins coincide with the appearance of all Eumachairodontia (with the exception of Amphimachairodus), i.e. true “saberteeth”. This is linked to major cranial modifications connected to the evolution of the characteristic hypertrophied and flattened upper canines. The continuous increase in occupied morphospace indicates that in machairodont felids real morphospace stabilization is never achieved until the Pleistocene, with the total representation of the Eumachairodontia. On the evolutionary level, the general group history seems to show a true Plio-Pleistocene radiation, identified by hyper-specialization, which led to a positive peak in disparity. The evolution of cranial disparity in machairodont felids can be included in the category of ‘top-heavy clade’, i.e. those groups who show a real radiation relatively late in their history.


Keywords


diversity; disparity; morphospace; sabertoothed felids; Cenozoic

Full Text:

PDF

References


Akersten W.A., 1985. Canine function in Smilodon (Mammalia; Felidae; Machairodontinae). Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, Los Angeles: 356, 1–22.

Antón M., Galobart A., 1999. Neck function and predatory behavior in the scimitar toothed cat Homotherium latidens (Owen). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 19, 771–784.

Antón M., Salesa M.J., Galobart A., Tseng Z.J., 2014. The Plio-Pleistocene scimitar-toothed felid genus Homotherium Fabrini, 1890 (Machairodontinae, Homotherini): diversity, palaeogeography and taxonomic implications. Quaternary Science Reviews: 96, 259–268.

Barnett R., Barnes I., Phillips M.J., Martin L.D., Harrington C.R., Leonard J.A., Cooper A., 2005. Evolution of the extinct sabretooths and the American cheetah-like cat. Current Biology: 15, R589–R590.

Benson R.B., Evans M., Druckenmiller P.S., 2012. High diversity, low disparity and small body size in plesiosaurs (Reptilia, Sauropterygia) from the Triassic–Jurassic boundary. PLoS One: 7, e31838.

Brusatte S.L., Benton M.J., Ruta M., Lloyd G.T., 2008. The first 50 Myr of dinosaur evolution: macroevolutionary pattern and morphological disparity. Biology Letters: 4, 733–736.

Brusatte S.L., Butler R.J., Prieto-Márquez A., Norell M.A,. 2012. Dinosaur morphological diversity and the end-Cretaceous extinction. Nature Communications: 3, 804.

Bryant H.N., 1996. Force generation by the jaw adductor musculature at different gapes in the Pleistocene sabertoothed felid Smilodon. In: Stewart K. M., Seymour K. L. (eds) Palaeoecology and palaeoenvironments of Late Cenozoic mammals—tributes to the career of C. S. (Rufus) Churcher. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 283–299

Butler R.J., Brusatte S.L., Andres B., Benson R.B.J., 2012. How do geological sampling biases affect studies of morphological evolution in deep time? A case study of pterosaur (Reptilia: Archosauria) disparity. Evolution: 66, 147–162.

Christiansen P., 2006. Sabertooth characters in the clouded leopard (Neofelis nebulosa Griffith, 1821). Journal of Morphology: 267, 1186–1198.

Christiansen P., 2007. Comparative biteforces and canine bending strengths in feline and sabretooth felids: implications for predatory ecology. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society: 151, 423–437.

Christiansen P., 2008a. Evolutionary convergence of primitive sabertooth craniomandibular morphology: the clouded leopard (Neofelis nebulosa) and Paramachairodus ogygia compared. Journal of Mammalian Evolution: 15, 155–179.

Christiansen P., 2008b. Species distinction and evolutionary differences in the clouded leopard (Neofelis nebulosa) and Diard’s clouded leopard (Neofelis diardi). Journal of Mammalogy: 89, 1435–1446.

Christiansen P., 2008c. Evolution of skull and mandible shape in cats (Carnivora: Felidae). PLoS ONE: 3, e2807.

Christiansen P., 2008d. Evolutionary changes in craniomandibular shape in the great cats (Neofelis Griffith and Panthera Oken). Biological journal of the Linnean Society: 95, 766–778

Christiansen P., 2013. Phylogeny of the sabertoothed felids (Carnivora: Felidae: Machairodontinae). Cladistics: 29, 543–559.

Deng T., Zhang Y.X., Tseng Z.J., Hou S.K., 2016. A skull of Machairodus horribilis and new evidence for gigantism as a mode of mosaic evolution in machairodonts (Felidae, Carnivora). Vertebrata PalAsiatica: 54, 302–318.

Duckler G.L., 1997. Parietal depressions in skulls of the extinct saber-toothed felid Smilodon fatalis: evidence of mechanical strain. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 17, 600–609.

Eble G.J., 2000. Contrasting evolutionary flexibility in sister groups: disparity and diversity in Mesozoic atelostomate echinoids. Paleobiology: 26, 56–79.

Emerson S.B., Radinsky L.B., 1980. Functional analysis of sabertooth cranial morphology. Paleobiology: 6, 295–312.

Erwin D.H., 2007. Disparity: morphological pattern and developmental context. Palaeontology: 50, 57–73.

Foote M., 1991. Morphological and taxonomic diversity in clade’s history: The blastoid record and stochastic simulations. Contributions from the Museum of Paleontology, University of Michigan: 28, 101–140.

Foote M., 1992. Rarefaction analysis of morphological and taxonomic diversity. Paleobiology: 18, 1–16.

Foote M., 1994. Morphological disparity in Ordovician-Devonian crinoids and the early saturation of morphological space. Paleobiology: 20, 320–344.

Foote M., 1995. Morphology of Carboniferous and Permian crinoids. Contributions from the Museum of Paleontology, University of Michigan: 29, 135–184.

Foote M., 1996. Ecological controls on the evolutionary recovery of post-Paleozoic crinoids. Science: 274, 1492–1495.

Foote M., 1997. Sampling, taxonomic description, and our evolving knowledge of morphological diversity. Paleobiology: 23, 181–206.

Foote M., 1999. Morphological diversity in the evolutionary radiation of Paleozoic and post-Paleozoic crinoids. Paleobiology: 25, 1–116.

Geraads D., Kaya T., Tuna V., 2004. A skull of Machairodus giganteus (Felidae, Mammalia) from the Late Miocene of Turkey. Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie Monatshefte: 2, 95–110.

Glaubrecht M., Brinkmann N., Pöppe J., 2009. Diversity and disparity ‘down under’: Systematics, biogeography and reproductive modes of the ‘marsupial’freshwater Thiaridae (Caenogastropoda, Cerithioidea) in Australia. Zoosystematics and Evolution: 85, 199–275.

Gould S.J., Gilinsky N.L., German R.Z., 1987. Asymmetry of lineages and the direction of evolutionary time. Science: 236, 1437–1441.

Halliday T.J.D., Goswami A., 2016. Eutherian morphological disparity across the end-Cretaceous mass extinction. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society: 118, 152–168.

Hammer Ø., 2013. PAST Paleontological Statistics Version 3.0: Reference Manual. University of Oslo.

Hammer Ø., Harper D.A.T., Ryan P.D., 2001. PAST: paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis. Palaeontologia electronica: 4, 9.

Hipsley C.A., Miles D.B., Müller J., 2014. Morphological disparity opposes latitudinal diversity gradient in lacertid lizards. Biology Letters: 10, 20140101.

Hopkins M.J., 2013. Decoupling of taxonomic diversity and morphological disparity during decline of the Cambrian trilobite family Pterocephaliidae. Journal of Evolutionary Biology: 26, 1665–1676.

Hughes M., Gerber S., Wills M.A., 2013. Clades reach highest morphological disparity early in their evolution. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences: 110, 13875–13879.

Huntley J.W., Xiao S.H., Kowalewski M., 2006. 1.3 billion years of acritarch history: an empirical morphospace approach. Precambrian Research: 144, 52–68.

Larson D.W., Brown C.M., Evans D.C., 2016. Dental disparity and ecological stability in bird-like dinosaurs prior to the end-Cretaceous mass extinction. Current Biology: 26, 1325–1333.

Lofgren A.S., Plotnick R.E., Wagner A.P.J., 2003. Morphological diversity of Carboniferous arthropods and insights on disparity patterns through the Phanerozoic. Paleobiology: 29, 349–368.

Kurtén B., Werdelin L., 1990. Relationships between North and South American Smilodon. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 10, 158–169.

Madurell-Malapeira J., Robles J.M., Casanovas-Vilar I., Abella J., Obradó P., Alba D.M., 2014. The scimitar-toothed cat Machairodus aphanistus (Carnivora: Felidae) in the Vallès-Penedès Basin (NE Iberian Peninsula). Comptes Rendus Palevol: 13, 569–585.

Martin L.D., 1980. Functional morphology and the evolution of cats. Nebraska Academy of Sciences Transactions: 8, 141–154.

Martin L.D., 1998a. Nimravidae. In: Janis C. M., Scott K. M., Jacobs L. L. (eds) Evolution of Tertiary mammals of North America, Vol. 1. Terrestrial carnivores, ungulates and ungulate-like mammals. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 228–235.

Martin L.D., 1998b. Felidae. In: Janis C. M., Scott K. M., Jacobs L. L. (eds) Evolution of Tertiary mammals of North America, Vol. 1. Terrestrial carnivores, ungulates and ungulate-like mammals. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 236–242.

Marx F.G., Fordyce R.E., 2015. Baleen boom and bust: a synthesis of mysticete phylogeny, diversity and disparity. Royal Society Open Science: 2, 140434.

McHenry C.R., Wroe S., Clausen P.D., Moreno K., Cunningham E., 2007. Supermodeled sabercat, predatory behavior in Smilodon fatalis revealed by high-resolution 3D computer simulation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences: 104, 16010–16015.

Monescillo M.F., Salesa M.J., Antón M., Siliceo G., Morales J., 2014. Machairodus aphanistus (Felidae, Machairodontinae, Homotherini) from the late Miocene (Vallesian, MN 10) site of Batallones-3 (Torrejón de Velasco, Madrid, Spain). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 34, 699–709.

Prentice K.C., Ruta M., Benton M.J., 2011. Evolution of morphological disparity in pterosaurs. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology: 9, 337–353.

Prevosti F.J., Turazzini G.F., Chemisquy A.M., 2010. Cranial morphology in sabertooth cats: allometry, function and phylogeny. Ameghiniana: 47, 239–256.

Radinsky L.B., Emerson S.B., 1982. The late, great sabertooths. Natural History: 91, 50–57.

Rawn-Schatzinger V., 1992. The scimitar cat Homotherium serum Cope. Illinois State Museum Reports of Investigation: 47, 1–80.

Riggs E.S., 1934. A new marsupial saber-tooth from the Pliocene of Argentina and its relationships to other South American predacious marsupials. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society: 24, 1–32.

Rincón A.D., Prevosti F.J., Parra G.E., 2011. New saber-toothed cat records (Felidae: Machairodontinae) for the Pleistocene of Venezuela, and the Great American Biotic Interchange. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 31, 468–478.

Romano M., 2017. Disparity vs. diversity in Stegosauria (Dinosauria, Ornithischia): cranial and post-cranial sub-dataset provide different signals. Historical Biology: DOI: 10.1080/08912963.2017.1397655.

Romano M., Brocklehurst N., Fröbisch J., 2017. Discrete and continuous character-based disparity analyses converge to the same macroevolutionary signal: a case study from captorhinids. Scientific reports: DOI: 10.1038/s41598-017-17757-5.

Romano M., Manni R., Brocklehurst N., Nicosia, U., 2018a. Multiphase morphospace saturation in cyrtocrinid crinoids. Lethaia: DOI:10.1111/let.12276.

Romano M., Sansom R., Randle M., 2018b. Morphospace saturation in the stem-gnathostomes Pteraspidiformes heterostracans: an early radiation of a ‘bottom’ heavy clade. PeerJ: 6, e5249, DOI 10.7717/peerj.5249.

Ruta M., 2009. Patterns of morphological evolution in major groups of Palaeozoic Temnospondyli (Amphibia: Tetrapoda). Special Papers in Palaeontology; 81, 91–120.

Ruta M., Angielczyk K.D., Fröbisch J., Benton M.J., 2013. Decoupling of morphological disparity and taxic diversity during the adaptive radiation of anomodont therapsids. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences: 280, 20131071.

Salesa M.J., Antón M., Turner A., Morales J., 2005. Aspects of the functional morphology in the cranial and cervical skeleton of the sabre-toothed cat Paramachairodus ogygia (Kaup 1832) (Felidae, Machairodontinae) from the Late Miocene of Spain: implications for the origins of the machairodont killing bite. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society: 144, 363–377.

Salesa M.J., Antón M., Turner A., Alcalá L., Montoy P., Morales J., 2010. Systematic revision of the Late Miocene sabretoothed felid Paramachaerodus in Spain. Palaeontology 53, 1369–1391.

Sardella R., 1998. The Plio-Pleistocene Old World dirk-toothed cat Megantereon ex gr. cultridens (Mammalia, Felidae, Machairodontinae), with comments on taxonomy, origin and evolution. Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie-Abhandlungen: 207, 1–36.

Scholz H., Hartma J.H., 2007. Paleoenvironmental reconstruction of the Upper Cretaceous Hell Creek Formation of the Williston Basin, Montana, USA: Implications from the quantitative analysis of unionoid bivalve taxonomic diversity and morphologic disparity. Palaios: 22, 24–34.

Siliceo G., Salesa M.J., Antón M., Monescillo M.F., Morales J., 2014. Promegantereon ogygia (Felidae, Machairodontinae, Smilodontini) from the Vallesian (late Miocene, MN 10) of Spain: morphological and functional differences in two noncontemporary populations. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 34, 407–418.

Simpson G.G., 1941. The function of saber-like canines in carnivorous mammals. American Museum novitates: 1130, 1–12.

Slater G.J., Van Valkenburgh B., 2008. Long in tooth: evolution of sabertooth cat cranial shape. Paleobiology: 34, 403–419.

Slater G.J., Price S.A., Santini F., Alfaro M.E., 2010. Diversity versus disparity and the radiation of modern cetaceans. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences: 277, 3097–3104.

Smith L.H., Lieberman B.S., 1999. Disparity and constraint in olenelloid trilobites and the Cambrian radiation. Paleobiology: 25, 459–470.

Sunquist M., Sunquist F., 2002. Wild Cats of the World. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 462 pp.

Therrien F., 2005. Feeding behaviour and bite force of sabretoothed predators. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society: 145, 393–426.

Turner A., Antón M., 1997. The Big Cats and their Fossil Relatives. An Illustrated Guide to their Evolution and Natural History. Columbia University Press, New York.

Van Valen L., 1974. Multivariate structural statistics in natural history. Journal of Theoretical Biology: 45, 235–247.

Van Valen L., 1978. The statistics of variation. Evolutionary Theory: 4, 33–43.

Van Valkenburgh B., 2001. Predation in saber-tooth cats. In: Briggs D.E.G., Crowthers P.R. (eds) Paleobiology II. Oxford, Blackwell Science, 420–424.

Van Valkenburgh B., 2007. Déjà vu: the evolution of feeding morphologies in the Carnivora. Integrative and Comparative Biology: 47, 147–163.

Van Valkenburgh B., Sacco T., 2002. Sexual dimorphism and intra-sexual competition in large Pleistocene carnivores. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology: 22, 164–169

Villier L., Eble G.J., 2004. Assessing the robustness of disparity estimates: the impact of morphometric scheme, temporal scale, and taxonomic level in spatangoid echinoids. Paleobiology: 30, 652–665.

Wallace S.C., Hulbert Jr R.C., 2013. A new machairodont from the Palmetto Fauna (Early Pliocene) of Florida, with comments on the origin of the Smilodontini (Mammalia, Carnivora, Felidae). PLoS one: 8, e56173.

Werdelin L., O’Brien S.J., Johnson W.E., Yamaguchi N., 2010. Phylogeny and evolution of cats (Felidae). In: Macdonald D.W., Loveridge A.J. (eds) Biology and Conservation of Wild Felids. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 60–82.

Whiteside J.H., Ward P.D., 2011. Ammonoid diversity and disparity track episodes of chaotic carbon cycling during the early Mesozoic. Geology: 39, 99–102.

Wills M.A., Briggs D.E.G., Fortey R.A., 1994. Disparity as an evolutionary index: a comparison of Cambrian and Recent arthropods. Paleobiology: 20, 93–131.

Zhu M., Schubert B.W., Liu J., Wallace S.C., 2014. A new record of the saber-toothed cat Megantereon (Felidae, Machairodontinae) from an Early Pleistocene Gigantopithecus fauna, Yanliang Cave, Fusui, Guangxi, South China. Quaternary international: 354, 100–109.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Copyright (c) 2019 Journal of Mediterranean Earth Sciences

ISSN Online: 2280-6148
ISSN Print: 2037-2272